Green in the City

Movie review: 'An Inconvenient Truth' **1/2

By Safiya Merchant

When the hype of the masses surrounds a film such as “An Inconvenient Truth,” it’s important to give the film a second look to gauge its true value.

A serene river and one of the most important insights into the human condition constitute the opening sequence in “An Inconvenient Truth,” former Vice President Al Gore’s 2006 attempt to debunk the myths surrounding global warming. He says we, as humans, often look at nature and wonder, “Oh, yeah, I forgot about this.” With technology fueling our every move, it is hard to deny we have lost recognition of earth’s most primitive habitat, the natural environment.

On April 3, 1989, Gore’s 6-year-old son was hit by a car and sent to the hospital. Gore describes the experience as an inspiration for re-evaluating his position on this planet, and to fight for the environment.

“An Inconvenient Truth” covers many topics, such as the frailty of the earth’s atmosphere, melting glaciers and tropical storms. According to Gore, 40 percent of the world population attains its drinking water from rivers fed by more than half of the glaciers’ meltwater. So the water supply will be drastically affected if the glaciers cease to exist. Another unfortunate result of rising water temperatures is stronger storms, such as Hurricane Katrina. When Katrina hit Florida, it was a Category One hurricane. But as it moved toward New Orleans—over warmer waters—its wind velocity and moisture content increased, becoming the catastrophe that dominated TV screens for weeks.

“An Inconvenient Truth” is an inconvenient film. It grabs viewers by the hair, forcing them to see the flaws in so many beliefs about this environmental issue. Gore uses graphics, facts, personal stories and even cartoons to expose the truth.

Although Gore’s attempts can be admired, I don’t think the graphics help spread the truth about global warming. They dehumanize the truth, reducing it to a mathematical equation. Human opinion and interviews about global warming would have made the film come to life, driving Gore’s message home.

The so-called potential victims of global warming never get a chance to speak. Because the film revolves around Gore speaking to a nameless audience in a dark room, it often feels like a publicity stunt for Gore—and so undercuts its message. For example, he shows before-and-after pictures of Mount Kilimanjaro and other landforms to demonstrate the deterioration of our planet. Asking those who lived near the mountain if this deterioration affected their present lives would have been more effective.

Despite these flaws, “An Inconvenient Truth” is worth the watch. It does provide information on a topic that is often ignored. For his part, Gore contends choosing to solve global warming “is not a political issue so much as a moral issue.” He says letting the environment continue to decay would be deeply “unethical.”

Throughout “An Inconvenient Truth,” Gore draws upon historical quotes like this from Winston Churchill: “We are entering a period of consequences.” Like Churchill, Gore knows that we have created— and now must deal with— our own period of consequences. According to Gore, to erase the pain man has inflicted on the environment, we must change our harmful lifestyles immediately.

Time will tell if the world will choose to heed his warning.


You need to be a member of Green in the City to add comments!

Join Green in the City





Bushra Kabir, Northside College Prep

Bri'anna Moore, Waukegan High School

Managing editors

Brenda Becerra, Curie High School

Amairani Galvan, Farragut Career Academy

Photo editors

Jasmine Johnson, Homewood-Flossmoor High School

Kimani Smith, Noble Street College Prep

Multimedia editors

LeJohn Montgomery, Hales Franciscan High School

Morgan Selvage, King College Prep

Contributing reporters

Carissa A. Eclarin, Schurz High School

Vivianna Galvan, Farragut Career Academy

Daniela Jurado, Farragut Career Academy

Safiya Merchant, Lane Tech High School

Demetria Taylor, Lindblom Math and Science Academy

Chad Wilson, Lindblom Math and Science Academy

Professional staff
Nancy Day, chair, Journalism Department, Columbia College

Workshop director:
Brenda Butler, media specialist and former Chicago Tribune senior features editor

Rui Kaneya, managing editor, The Chicago Reporter

Maudlyne Ihejirika, assistant city editor, Chicago Sun-Times

Charlie Meyerson, former Chicago Tribune online editor, now WGN-AM news director

Billy Montgomery, reporter, photographer, professor, Columbia College

Lynn Norment, former Ebony Magazine managing editor, now media relations specialist, Carol H. Williams Agency

Antonio Olivo, immigration reporter, Chicago Tribune

Nancy Traver, professor and writing coach, Columbia College

Avis Weathersbee, former Chicago Sun-Times assistant managing editor, now blogger and writer/editor

Cassandra West, former Womanews editor, Chicago Tribune, now writer and photographer

Mike Zajakowski, picture editor, Chicago Tribune

© 2018   Created by Columbia Links.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service